Comic quest is an amazing place to hang out. Monty is a fantastic owner who runs his shop like a well oiled machine. I have been there several times for Pokemon events and each time I feel welcomed and included if I’m playing or just watching my husband play. I’m originally from Evansville, But I didn’t start going to Comic Quest until I met my husband and started playing Pokémon with him. I wish I would have found out about this place sooner. They have a little bit of everything for every type of person. I highly recommend visiting. You don’t be disappointed.

Comic Quest sells comics, collecitbles and nerdy games like Magic the Gathering and Yugioh cards. Today I brought a group of students to play in their Yugioh tournament. They have a rather large area dedicated to playing the tournaments. Im sure the students will want to come again.

Largest comic store Ive been to around the area! Great selection of products and professional customer service. Staff is friendly and knowledgeable about products. Would highly recommend to anyone with any general pop culture interest. They have something for everyone.

Comic quest is an excellent family friendly place. Ive taken my nephew there many times to play pokemon and magic. Im a writer and they allowed me to do a book signing event there, which was awesome. Its got a good selection of games and magic cards and plenty of interesting events.

They had some cool stuff. This caught my attention.

I’ve been going here for about 6 or 7 years almost every Friday for Pokémon night! They are so nice and considerate! It’s great!!

I always spend way too much money here, so theyre doing something right.

Been shopping at this store for years! Excellent selection and workers are always helpful in finding what I’m looking for. My son loves playing Pokémon on Friday nights here. Highly recommended!

Love this store! Biggest in the area and a huge selection. Weekly comics and usually every variant, great magic selection and community, and a great selection of board games for sale and free to play in store. Great Funko pop area and kids area and largest selection of toys, figures, collectibles, and statues.

The store has some interesting items, particularly for game enthusiasts. We stopped in to browse and found a great deal on a board game that I had been wanting. The merchandise is pretty good overall but the prices are a little high unless you find a good deal. The real issue is the staff. They never greet us when we come in and act like processing the purchase is putting them out. We have had this same experience multiple times at the store. They seem friendly to the people who come in and play games but not to shoppers like us. They do seem a little friendlier to my boyfriend than to me. For this reason, I prefer shopping at a similar store in Owensboro where I feel welcomed even though it requires a bit of a drive.

Tons of action figures and collectibles to choose from besides the huge amount of comics and series. Support local business and give this place a try. Really cool store.

Everyone was nice and jolly when me and my sister went there! Lovely surrounding! Thank you!

My son & I love this place!!!! It has comics that I grew up on (KISS comics & so forth), & since my son is getting back into comics; Comic Quest is the most reasonable place to go to. More bang for your buck!!! Plus they also have arcade games you can play & board games also!!!

Had to change the ratings on this one because I called and asked about selling cards and when they say come on in I get there and he no longer is willing to even look at them and says his magic guy isnt even in when I adked why he said to come in and he would then refuse to look at them he said he thought it make me more likely to buy something anyways YEAH RIGHT THATS BS NO MORE BUSINESS FROM ME AND I HAVE SHOPPED THERE FOR GOING ON 26 YEARS EHAT A SHAME

Ive been doing to coming quest for at least 10+ years and Ive always had a great experience and thoroughly enjoy their wide selection and the arcade fames!

This store is VERY poorly run. Wizards of the Coast has recently released a new promotion called the Love Your LGS promotion where you receive a promo Reliquary Tower for making any purchase in store. Again ANY PURCHASE. Here let me quote from their official release:To start with, make any purchase or buy any event entry (including store-run online events), and you can receive the Reliquary Tower (limit one per customer, while supplies last).As per the norm Comic Quest has skewed this promotion and is requiring you buy 6 booster packs, a minimum $25+ purchase after tax, to acquire this promo card. That was not Wizards intent when releasing this card. I have given this store chance after chance and every time I go in there they are price gouging, practically selling promo cards, or just plain rude. Heck I was once laughed at for asking the price of a From The Vault set that they had tripled the price of. This store should really be shut down for their poor practices and I will be reporting them to Wizards for fraud investigation.

I spent my Saturday afternoon going from game store to game store all over the Newburgh and Evansville area looking for a place to sell some fairly expensive Magic: The Gathering cards for cash, and Comic Quest was the only store to give me a reasonable price (or even take them at all). The man behind the counter was friendly and throughout the entire process he kept me entertained and informed me on what events the store hold day to day. I will definitely be returning and can guarantee that this local game store is worth going to.

Walking into Comic Quest, felt like walking into my childhood!

One of the best comic shops around. My 1st choice in town for my Geeky needs.

Excellent experience. They let you look around but offer help if needed. So many cool things to look at! Its one of my favorite destinations to go.

Thanks for ruining Pokemon. Gougers

Every time I go to Comic Quest I have a great experience. Very friendly employees and customers.

Amazing store with an old school feel. The place is huge and has so many comics, collectibles, board games and much more. There are many huge gaming tables that visitors can play games on. There is a shelf filled with open games that can be played in store for free and there are even arcade games! Great place!

Always have what I need at a good price

Logan was very helpful. Great store, cool stuff. Ill be back!

I was travelling this weekend and swung in here for a spur of the moment venture. Glad I did because this store is awesome! They have everything from collectibles, comics, every card ever it seemed and more! The staff were friendly as ever and they even went out of their way to get my nephew and son into Magic the Gathering! They went home happy as ever! Will definitely be back.

Monti is a pretty cool dude. brought back memories of playing in the card shop when I was a kid. pretty neat retro arcade play for a set fee. good deal!

Lke a second family. I miss playing MTG here!

I have been going here for over twenty years now and I have seen the ups and downs of the store. I would like to trade almost my entire collection here but they are shady about only wanting to accept old vintage books and not new stuff that is over flowing my home that I would get rid of along with older, vintage books. If they would take my newer stuff I would trade old stuff that has high value. The store is ok for the most part but for someone that has been going here for twenty plus years and yet won’t do a solid and help me out by trading my new and old comics hurts me greatly. I do feel like this store is way better than the one in Owensboro by far and knowing both owners real well I can say that I have great respect for the one in Evansville. I will say though you want to get vintage books comic quest you need to be able to take all the books on trade not just a few vintage books I have heard to many people complain about the way you guys trade! Also I went in there and asked a question to the worker at the register on 2-29-20 and he said he didn’t know the answer to my question about a comic nor did he even try to look anything up for me. I also hate that they will not price match certain books or comics to some retail as some things in the store is very overpriced. I miss the good old days when Lelani was running the store you got help and so much more. Not only that but if I want comics and graphic novels cheaper now there are comic book stores with apps and online service to where you can order comics and other things two weeks ahead of time and when it gets released you get the items cheaper than cover price to make up for shipping cost and delivered to my door on the day the comics are set to release. If they want my business again then they will accept trade ins no matter weather they are vintage or newer books. Lastly Amazon sells graphic novels way cheaper than comic book stores now. It just taught me I can’t be a slave to the comic book stores anymore when it comes to hardcovers and tpbs.

Visited this store today, I purchased a miniature figure. As I was walking to me vehicle I noticed the figure was broken. (Didnt even make it to the car) I got our baby buckled in while my wife went back to exchange the figure. The store did not have another in stock and offered to order one, we are from out of town so that would not work. The store then offered to give us store credit for the figure, again we are from out of town. They refused a refund stating that as soon as we walk out the door they will not refund. It was a $5 figure and we paid in cash. They still would not let us have a refund for the broken figure (the figure wasnt just broken there was a piece completely missing, and the package was unopened. I am very dissapointed and will not be returning to this store, which might not seem like a big deal since I am from out of town but we visit frequently.

Friendly staff you can meet people there that will give you good tips and amazing collectibles

This place is absolutely pathetic I was in there 10 minutes walking around the whole store looking at their merchandise they had some really good pieces I was interested in but not one time did they asked me if I needed any help they were too busy looking at trading cards then to acknowledge a customer walking around in their store funny part was I was the only customer in the store

Great book store for our area. It is well organized but still a little difficult to find specific titles you maybe looking for. The staff was helpful when asked I guess I could have relied on them more. I will be returning for sure.

Always a great stop! They have such a variety of items from funko pops, to comic books, and a ton of card games! The workers are all friendly and will help you find whatever you need. If youre a nerd like myself, youll love it!

Great selection for almost any person. Comics of most genres, anime figures, manga, DC, Marvel, retro figures, etc. Prices send to be MSRP which is good because they arent upping their prices like other stores Ive visited.

Best. Store. Ever. They have friendly employees who are very knowledgeable about all their products and even stick around after they are off to interact with us (customers) who come in to play consistently. Full arcade and snacks? Yes please!!!!

Its a neat little store with a lot of gaming and comic vibe.

Pokemon pokemon its wild, tons of battles on Friday nights.

Lots of comics and collectables,old and new. Game tables for card games, full size action figures (five feet tall) and more. Cool place.

The quentessnt gamers store. Only reason I didnt give it 5 stars is the outside parking lot is a little wore and the strip mall its in is a little older.

They have lots of games, comic books, d&d supplies and more. Definitely worth checking out.

Bery fun night of magic the gathering. I would reccomend coming if you play.

Love this place. Enjoy going with my family

Love this place! Such a welcoming atmosphere, and everyone behind the counter is always friendly, willing to help inform any sceptics about any of their merchandise, and either explain how to play or nights they can play with others.I will always be a patron

So amazing and fun to go inside the store, there is so many things to look at!

Pretty nice selection of items here. Prices are about average and fair compared to other places. Only giving 3 stars because the staff is just not very friendly. I think it is a father and son who mainly run the place (??) I could be wrong, but that is what it looks like... they are so rude and not personable whatsoever.

Great place great people great service

Fantastic store with an unbelievable selection of comics and comic based merchandise. And much much more. If youre a comic book fanatic or you like board game ir card games. Definitely stop by.

Very friendly I will be coming back!

Nice enough comic book shop. They have a lot of what people are looking for. the inside however is very dingy appears to be old and just not very well kept

Great place to buy and play card games. The staff is very friendly.

You name it, theyve probably got it. A Mecca for tabletop and video gamers, DnD/GERPS players, comic/movie/CCG/anime/action figure fans, and geek culture lovers. Lots of great card tournaments and other events too.

Excellent service and selection!!

Very nice place, good back stock of comics and collectibles!

A great place for all of your DnD, Magic the Gathering and more

Why does Google think I was here. I selected I havent been here, but Google chooses to tell me I visited it like 3 weeks ago. I selected Dismiss the 2nd time, and immediately get this request for review... 3rd time. Sorry Comic Quest, but take up this rating with Google for ignoring me, and refusing to acknowledge I HAVENT BEEN HERE

Store layout is a cluttered mess. They have many items youd like to look at behind a counter that you arent allowed to go behind,yet it has priceless comics out in the open for anyone to just ruin the value of by picking up and handling. There is an arcade machine that makes an awful noise every few seconds and makes the shopping experience even worse.

Love this place! There is always new stock and the workers are very helpful. Its a comic lovers paradise!

Great selection of comics from Marvel and DC to indie comics. Good selection of games. They even have an arcade now. Lots of collectable toys. They host card game tournaments and free comic book day events.

Comic Quest is a great place to meet cool people with the same like mindedness. It is literally fun for all ages. MTG on Friday night is awesome. All of the staff are friendly and help you with anything.

Nice and large store plently of room for playing cards, doesnt sell or buy Yu-Gi-Oh singles though. Sells packs and boxes though.

Best comic store Ive seen

Always great help and service on anything

Fun, family atmosphere. Lots of stuff!

Great comic book shop with knowledgeable employees.

Friendly atmosphere great selection

Very very good store for the cómic fans a lot of cómic books and colectibles !!!!

Amazing store, always knowledgeable staff on hand. Can usually find a pick up game with a patron. Always pleased when I go in even just to look around.

Great service, large selection of cards, comics, and figurines.

This is the largest comic book store I have ever been in. It is well organized and staff are always there to help find what you are looking for. They also sell games, toys and collectibles. It is a hard location to find and the parking lot is not kept up but the inside of the store is clean and organized.

Love this place i can play what ever game i want the people that run it are so nice

My neck beard wasnt thick enough... so much inventory.....thats good though right

I love coming here. The staff and other customers are very inviting. There is a very large selection of stuff to choose from here for any game of comics.

The day I visited the store was setup for a table top tournament which made the store a little difficult to navigate but was totally fine as there was quite a turnout. Probably the only good comic shop in the area. Store seems to cater to all breeds of nerd...in a good way :)

The best comic shop with DND!

Great place, I have been going for seven years and seen the love and support shown through this place. I honestly would live there if I could. Great selection of everything a card gaming nerd or a comic enthusiest could want. I personally know all the staff and their ways of handling things. The previous reviews that have been negative are untrue, there truly is no better place in town for what Comic Quest offers.

Great shop with excellent atmosphere. I can always find what I need here.

Great selection of stuff, cool staff, cool clientel

Good store very helpful

Great local place to get your comics, games, trade paperbacks, pop figures and so much more. Very helpful, friendly, family ran store!

This store will definitely satisfy your quest for your favorite comics.

Great collection of comics, trading cards, and collectables.

Comic Quest is the most welcoming comic book and gaming store in the Tri-State area. The employees are always happy to help and there are so many games and toys and comics to choose from! Plus there is SO MUCH ROOM to sit down with your friends and play games for FREE!!! Definitely my favorite go-to place for games and more here in Evansville!

Active game shop. Tons of stuff for sale. You can just go in and grab an open table to play games.

Nice selection of old & new comics as well as toys and games. Comics could be better organized.

Came for the national Free Comic Book day event. Great selection of comics, games, and memorabilia. Friendly staff, clean store. Great place to find what you are looking for!

Terrible prices way over priced and dont negotiate.

Best comic and game store in town

Wonderful place to spend time!

Had great time, Cool Cats/me so Hangry Grill was there along with celebrities.

Always find great deals.

Great place! Great atmosphere! Fantastic employees!

They set a standard for all stores in courtesy and creating a welcoming environment. And they exceed all standards when it comes to comics and gaming. Not only the best shop in the area, but one of the best Ive been to in the US.

This place is heaven for the nerd in me! So much selection! The vintage arcade is a nice touch with some epic childhood favorites! An absolute must everytime I am in town.

Awesome will go again

Always love coming here. Staff is excellent and knowledgeable of past and upcoming games. Prices are reasonable and selection is top notch.

Big store with great selection. Weekly events for popular TCG, and Miniatures games. Friendly staff. They have recently added more open tables for playing games which is great!

Great stock and friendly, knowledgeable service every time we visit

Love this place!!!

Good product selection and theyve really cleaned the place up! Friendly, personal service is still a concern of mine, but its definitely improved.